Welcome to ScapeCrunch

We are ScapeCrunch, the place where planted aquarium hobbyists come to build relationships and support each other. When you're tired of doom scrolling, you've found your home here.

UNS Controsoil in nitrate limited tank

Joined
Nov 16, 2026
Messages
9
Reaction score
25
Location
San Diego
Has any one had any experience with Controsoil in an nitrate limited system? I'd like to color up my Rotala H'Ra more than it is now and have been keeping my NO3 at around, or slightly under 5PPM but still above 0 while slowing ramping up my lighting intensity so I don't knockout the balance of the system. I've got the usual nice salmon pink tips you usually get with this cultivar, but wouldn't mind getting it a bit more red as I continue to ramp up the light even brighter. I've read that in order to do so, you really need to get the NO3 to as close to 0PPM as possible (along with of course, bright light and optimal CO2). I'm just concerned about having hair algae exploding again, but this time from nutrient limitation after finally getting it under control for the opposite reason.

I know that Controsoil doesn't have anywhere near the same ammonium content as Amazonas, but was wondering if there was enough nitrate in it to sufficiently supply my H'Ra with NO3 through the roots so I could run the system close to 0PPM on NO3 without having to use root tabs. I'm getting conflicting info- some sources say there's effectively zero nitrogen content in Controsoil, but a video from Buce Plant on nitrate limited coloration specifically names UNS Controsoil as ideal for this method. Would be curious to see if anyone has any first hand experience, or has enough concrete info to settle this.
 
How old is the controsoil ? I have a year old apt feast which I am sure is depleted and had been doing ok with just apt jazz. Just to say that the aquasoil does play a role but there are probably other factors.

My tanks are at about 0-1 ppm, plants get hair algae if there is more of a bump in nitrates in my nitrate limited system.

Not your question, but if in search for reds with nitrate limitation, I find rotala blood red to get much redder than HRA.
 
How old is the controsoil ? I have a year old apt feast which I am sure is depleted and had been doing ok with just apt jazz. Just to say that the aquasoil does play a role but there are probably other factors.

My tanks are at about 0-1 ppm, plants get hair algae if there is more of a bump in nitrates in my nitrate limited system.

Not your question, but if in search for reds with nitrate limitation, I find rotala blood red to get much redder than HRA.
It's around 6 months old now so not the freshest batch. I love the color of blood red, but I have a pico tank that's only 2.5gals and thought the leaves on Hra fit the scale of my tiny tank a little better than the other cultivars. Also, I love the that spilling over, weeping willow look that HRA can get. It's not the end of the world though if I can't get in any redder than it is- it still looks great!
 
In my limited experience with my lean dosing, lack of nitrogen in the substrate typically manifests as stunting and lack of branching. Rotala HRa and blood red seem to care way less about this than some other plants. They do probably need some but relatively less than other plants. If your HRa is growing at a steady speed and branching well then The substrate is not an issue. If you want it to get it redder it might just need more light.
 
Works well until it doesn't.

Had a tank filled with bucephalandras in controsoil with high co2 injection. Lean Dosing as well.
Grew everything perfectly for a few months. Buces grew very red/blue, super colorful as you would get with some nitrate limitation.
Then everything completely stopped growing and some plants stopped growing and some started fragmenting.

I think you might be better off just mixing in some new substrate periodically.

I've read some people recommend adding in Urea/Ammonia instead of Nitrate for Nitrogen instead for lean dosing as it works better.
 
I would just follow this, 2 hour write up on this. I will say Controsoil has almost zero soil level nitrogen. It is good at PH buffering but has no ammonium and no nitrate after a few water changes it is already exhausted. I am likely never using it again. Too many other options for a similar price.
 
I would just follow this, 2 hour write up on this. I will say Controsoil has almost zero soil level nitrogen. It is good at PH buffering but has no ammonium and no nitrate after a few water changes it is already exhausted. I am likely never using it again. Too many other options for a similar price.
Ok that’s what I’ve been hearing mostly as well. It was just that one Buce plant video I saw that contradicted all the other sources.
 

Top 10 Trending Threads

Back
Top