Welcome to ScapeCrunch

We are ScapeCrunch, the place where planted aquarium hobbyists come to build relationships and support each other. When you're tired of doom scrolling, you've found your home here.

There’s a dumpster fire happening on r/Aquascape

I still say reddit is better than facebook for most things. The majority of plant and fish groups on facebook are mostly people with 2 weeks of experience giving advice to people with 1 week of experience. I always love seeing a Dennis Wong tank pop up on facebook - half the comments are "do you use co2?"
 
Beautiful 😁😁😁 did I miss your journal on this? 🫣 Would really love to see how you got this put together!

View attachment 21771
I did this one before I discovered the forum. It was my first real big "aquascape" tank so I went with greening to try and simplify ease of ownership as it is in my living room and my wife would not be patient with me always getting my hands in there. I really need to thin the ferns again. I also added plants on the substrate to help my cichlids have territory.
Original post
 
Last edited:
All I could think all day was was:

1795112573869.webp

My wording on my post wasn't thought out, and I came to agree with most of the grievances people took with my post (and even came to understand them), but DAMN. I didn't attack anyone, but people sure wanted to attack me lol

I was called elitist, clown, asshole, dick, gatekeeper, pretentious. Yikes, I've never been called those things in my life! I'm pretty sure I'm NOT those things, but holy moly the hivemind of Reddit did not like it.

Also someone told me my scapes were "average", and people agreed. Like cmon now. I'm no expert but I think I'm a bit above the average hobbyist, I'd hope...

I know I wasn't alone in my expressed sentiment, but the sheer number of bad faith arguments and assumptions about what I meant was mindblowing. I shouldn't have mentioned anything about beginners... it's not beginners that were ruining the quality of the community, it's the extremely low-quality, low-effort, and/or unrelated post that beginners began flooding the sub with. Years ago, it genuine wasn't like that. That's what I was trying to have a discussion around, and see if we could step up and prevent. But my wording genuinely triggered people as if I had personally attacked them, despite the fact that the Mods of the sub implemented basically many little changes aligned with what I suggested?? They just used better language than I did, and people loved it.

Users hyperfixated on the title, didn't read anything else I commented or posted, threw insults, and called for me to be banned?? So, not much will change. That community will stay a slightly higher end clone of r/plantedtank and other facebook groups, but I don't think I'll be participating much anymore. I don't mind helping beginners, but if I'm going to spend my precious time on this planet looking at a screen, I like to spend it looking at tanks or scapes that inspire me (like so, so many countless tanks here do!). I DON'T follow facebook groups, or r/plantedtank because the quality just isn't there.

Does that mean I think those groups should be deleted? wtf, no. But that's the kind of logic that redditors used on my post yesterday...

I fully agree with @ample and basically everyone in discussion here:
Reddit will always be an open forum catering to the lowest common denominator. Nobody wants to see what years of focused practice produce, and will write off any decent aquascape or skilled plant husbandry as either having “thousands of dollars to spend” or just gatekeeping and elitism. Just let them have it. There’s no meaningful discussion to be had over there anyway.

There's so much misinformation spread in that community already. If I read "excess nutrients" from a very amateur scaper one more time...
😭

Anyway. Thank god for all of you wonderful people on Scapecrunch. You guys know me, I love helping people out and especially helping beginners. Tone cannot be conveyed well over the internet, but I think anyone who sees my posts and content should feel that I'm a genuine community member with non-AI, quality posts, usually upbeat and helpful but I only feel like I can do that here at SC without wanting to bash my head in because the nature of Scapecrunch's forum style means that even beginners have to put in a little effort into their posts, which makes it so much more desirable to help them.

Long live SC ❤️
 
Already left Reddit, and my overall experience with the website hasn't been good, especially when it comes to asking for relationship advice and getting weird downvotes for no reason, lmao.

One time, I posted a photo of Pothos (the actual genus Pothos, not Epipremnum) growing on a tree in a rainforest in southern Thailand in one subreddit, and a member insisted that what they were seeing was bamboo.

Another time, someone posted a rare Aponogeton queenslandicus in r/PlantedTank, and almost all the replies claimed it was very common because of the bulbs sold at PetSmart.

Someone else asked where guppies originated, and all they got in response was "Planet Guppington."

Now I always wonder, where have all the experts gone? Surely there must be actual botanists or ichthyologists answering questions there. Or are the experts just too afraid to chime in?
 
where have all the experts gone?
Genuinely right here. I haven't seen better tanks with more knowledge than Scape Crunch. The fact that we have legends in the hobby who frequently participate here is incredible.
 
I was called elitist, clown, asshole, dick, gatekeeper, pretentious. Yikes, I've never been called those things in my life! I'm pretty sure I'm NOT those things
1795114647000.webp

gotta take it all for what it’s worth, the difference is Reddit isn’t a true community.
 
I still say reddit is better than facebook for most things.
Personally, I think Reddit is terrible. For Facebook you really have to find an actual niche group.
For example if you’re a plant collector and want to keep it optimally, it’s better to search for Plant genus or Family name, there you’ll find actual nerds:

Rheophytes: Facebook
Cryptocoryne: Facebook
Cryptocoryne: https://m.facebook.com/groups/195323491200979/?ref=share
Cryptocoryne: https://m.facebook.com/groups/Cryptocoryne/?ref=share
Echinodorus: https://m.facebook.com/groups/852912099147005/?ref=share
International Aroid Society (For Identifying Aroids): https://m.facebook.com/groups/internationalaroidsociety/?ref=share
Rare Miniature Terrarium Plants: https://m.facebook.com/groups/RareMiniatureTerrariumPlants/?ref=share
Really Rare Plants: https://m.facebook.com/groups/2922785097948853/?ref=share
Genlisea, Utricularia, Aldrovanda, Philcoxia: https://m.facebook.com/groups/genlisea.utricularia.aldrovanda/?ref=share
 
Last edited:
All I could think all day was was:

View attachment 21778

My wording on my post wasn't thought out, and I came to agree with most of the grievances people took with my post (and even came to understand them), but DAMN. I didn't attack anyone, but people sure wanted to attack me lol

I was called elitist, clown, asshole, dick, gatekeeper, pretentious. Yikes, I've never been called those things in my life! I'm pretty sure I'm NOT those things, but holy moly the hivemind of Reddit did not like it.

Also someone told me my scapes were "average", and people agreed. Like cmon now. I'm no expert but I think I'm a bit above the average hobbyist, I'd hope...

I know I wasn't alone in my expressed sentiment, but the sheer number of bad faith arguments and assumptions about what I meant was mindblowing. I shouldn't have mentioned anything about beginners... it's not beginners that were ruining the quality of the community, it's the extremely low-quality, low-effort, and/or unrelated post that beginners began flooding the sub with. Years ago, it genuine wasn't like that. That's what I was trying to have a discussion around, and see if we could step up and prevent. But my wording genuinely triggered people as if I had personally attacked them, despite the fact that the Mods of the sub implemented basically many little changes aligned with what I suggested?? They just used better language than I did, and people loved it.

Users hyperfixated on the title, didn't read anything else I commented or posted, threw insults, and called for me to be banned?? So, not much will change. That community will stay a slightly higher end clone of r/plantedtank and other facebook groups, but I don't think I'll be participating much anymore. I don't mind helping beginners, but if I'm going to spend my precious time on this planet looking at a screen, I like to spend it looking at tanks or scapes that inspire me (like so, so many countless tanks here do!). I DON'T follow facebook groups, or r/plantedtank because the quality just isn't there.

Does that mean I think those groups should be deleted? wtf, no. But that's the kind of logic that redditors used on my post yesterday...

I fully agree with @ample and basically everyone in discussion here:


There's so much misinformation spread in that community already. If I read "excess nutrients" from a very amateur scaper one more time...
😭

Anyway. Thank god for all of you wonderful people on Scapecrunch. You guys know me, I love helping people out and especially helping beginners. Tone cannot be conveyed well over the internet, but I think anyone who sees my posts and content should feel that I'm a genuine community member with non-AI, quality posts, usually upbeat and helpful but I only feel like I can do that here at SC without wanting to bash my head in because the nature of Scapecrunch's forum style means that even beginners have to put in a little effort into their posts, which makes it so much more desirable to help them.

Long live SC ❤️
Wait so you have two accounts and posted that? First of all thanks for approving my scape lol. Second you weren't wrong. Lastly now I feel bad about my joke about starting a riot over EI dosing next.

For the record I was called a hateful POS and was hate messaged for calling out the Pothos comment to George Farmer a year ago. It stopped me going on Reddit at all for months. It's a good thing as this forum taught me I was starving my plants and even convinced me to add GH to my tap.
 
Personally it's been fun to watch the drama unfold and comment here or there. I ride the fence on the issue - I can see why people who are just unskilled beginners want a place to post and learn, while I can also see that the more advanced want to see similar (and used to on the sub). I saw the reactions to your post @Naturescapes_Rocco and I feel like the reaction was very reddit, and a lot of BS. Your tanks are not average at all lmao.

I enjoy Reddit and I think its a step up from Facebook, but yeah, it's not exactly a great place to find advanced work or discussion. Especially with like many of you have said, aquascaping is getting more popular, so it's becoming full of more and more beginners, and people who want to feel accepted. I know I would want my tanks to be "approved" as aquascapes, as a beginner myself, but I feel like there are many "beginner" posts there that still don't really belong.

The funny thing is, the new actions by the moderators seem to show a different story than the majority of the commenters there. Looking at the various new rules and tags and things the mods announced, most of them would be "gatekeeper-friendly" compared to "beginner-friendly" (using those labels since those were the clear two "sides" in this debate).

Either way, I think the mod's response was good, and I think this drama will blow over like most memes do.
 
Wait so you have two accounts and posted that? First of all thanks for approving my scape lol. Second you weren't wrong. Lastly now I feel bad about my joke about starting a riot over EI dosing next.

For the record I was called a hateful POS and was hate messaged for calling out the Pothos comment to George Farmer a year ago. It stopped me going on Reddit at all for months. It's a good thing as this forum taught me I was starving my plants and even convinced me to add GH to my tap.
Oh no, there was two people involved. The first guy (I think they've nicknamed him That Guy) wasn't me, but I read his post, felt I was in agreement, and also made my own post (which I deleted after I was swamped with notifications). It's a team effort out there, but I've only got one account on Reddit!
 
Oh no, there was two people involved. The first guy (I think they've nicknamed him That Guy) wasn't me, but I read his post, felt I was in agreement, and also made my own post (which I deleted after I was swamped with notifications). It's a team effort out there, but I've only got one account on Reddit!
Don’t let the whole thing get you down. You’ve made awesome tanks, and they don’t know what they’re missing! Some people just live for drama.
 
Oh no, there was two people involved. The first guy (I think they've nicknamed him That Guy) wasn't me, but I read his post, felt I was in agreement, and also made my own post (which I deleted after I was swamped with notifications). It's a team effort out there, but I've only got one account on Reddit!
Ahh I never saw it. Yeah you jumped into a feeding frenzy lol. You did nothing wrong, feel free to chime in on my tanks and what to fix. Good times.
 
I was called elitist, clown, asshole, dick, gatekeeper, pretentious. Yikes, I've never been called those things in my life! I'm pretty sure I'm NOT those things, but holy moly the hivemind of Reddit did not like it.
Exactly. I saw it all unfold and felt horrible. It was literally in response to you pulling up receipts of all of the ways you've demonstrably contributed so much valuable content to the subreddit in the past, too. Once the hive mind decides on a target, civility goes out the window. And the loser calling your tanks average just to put you down was so scummy, but I expect nothing less. You should have left the post up, but I understand why you took it down. It's all the evidence anyone needs to understand what kind of culture they're fostering there. I'm pretty ready to unsubscribe now, especially since every single post is now some snarky karma whoring variation of "iS mY bOX oF sTiCkS aNd rOCkS goOd eNoUGh to bE a sCaPe?"
 

Top 10 Trending Threads

Back
Top