I think people are fixating on the term “intentional.” While we understand what it means to design a tank with intent, the crusaders over there are just arguing that ANY placement decision is a choice, therefore it is intentional, and thus every attempt is art, and an aquascape.
Someone on one of the threads commented about every art form including aquascaping having some basis in theory, and I think that would have been a much clearer idea to emphasize. I also think calling aquascaping just an “art” does it a disservice. It’s a skilled discipline that requires some level of practice and understanding. Like with any art, some people have a natural inclination and can create good aquascapes without much experience, while most have to try, fail, and study many times before gradually progressing over time.
Anyhow, the entire discussion has completely degraded. It’s a shame, but that’s what the loud majority want. Hopefully those who would like to grow in this discipline make their way over here to engage with like minded folk.