Welcome to ScapeCrunch

We are ScapeCrunch, the place where planted aquarium hobbyists come to build relationships and support each other. When you're tired of doom scrolling, you've found your home here.

There’s a dumpster fire happening on r/Aquascape

Joined
Feb 24, 2026
Messages
104
Reaction score
207
Location
Houston, TX
Saw a couple of you guys fighting for your lives over on Reddit. Valiant effort, but it’s just not the space for this hobby. Reddit will always be an open forum catering to the lowest common denominator. Nobody wants to see what years of focused practice produce, and will write off any decent aquascape or skilled plant husbandry as either having “thousands of dollars to spend” or just gatekeeping and elitism. Just let them have it. There’s no meaningful discussion to be had over there anyway.
 
I took a quick look. It seems a lot of people just want to intentionally misunderstand what is being said, and use it get attention for themselves, instead of having a meaningful discussion. It’s too bad…
 
I agree that the quality of that subreddit has been degrading. With "aquascaping" becoming slightly more mainstream there are many people new to it that don't know the culture or history in which the discipline originated. To them their Amazon sword/java fern/anubias tank is aquascaped because it has a piece of hardscape in it and it looks just like Master Aquascaper Cory McElroy's tanks that they've seen on youtube.
 
I think people are fixating on the term “intentional.” While we understand what it means to design a tank with intent, the crusaders over there are just arguing that ANY placement decision is a choice, therefore it is intentional, and thus every attempt is art, and an aquascape.

Someone on one of the threads commented about every art form including aquascaping having some basis in theory, and I think that would have been a much clearer idea to emphasize. I also think calling aquascaping just an “art” does it a disservice. It’s a skilled discipline that requires some level of practice and understanding. Like with any art, some people have a natural inclination and can create good aquascapes without much experience, while most have to try, fail, and study many times before gradually progressing over time.

Anyhow, the entire discussion has completely degraded. It’s a shame, but that’s what the loud majority want. Hopefully those who would like to grow in this discipline make their way over here to engage with like minded folk.
 
Anyhow, the entire discussion has completely degraded. It’s a shame, but that’s what the loud majority want. Hopefully those who would like to grow in this discipline make their way over here to engage with like minded folk.
Yep, that's why I left the FB "aquascaping" groups and only post occasionally in the reddit groups when I want to get an ego boost by all the oohs and ahs, or I see some one getting blatantly bad advice (to be fair, that's more often in the planted tank group). 😁
 
This is how the aquarium hobby spaces as a whole are on Reddit. I’ve seen very similar things regarding one of the other rabbit holes I’m stuck in, Medaka. Reddit has been very hostile towards people trying to organize and put some standards of care into how breeding etc is done. Suggestions that largely amount to “hey maybe we should all work harder on producing quality fish” are met with sometimes truly wild amounts of venom.

I once saw someone in the general aquarium subreddit confidently asserting zebra danio breeder boxes used in lab production were bad and wouldn’t work because zebra danios form life long pair bonds. The psychic damage I was dealt by that has been enough to keep me away for a while 😆
 
I'm not sure if I'm on board with the changes they're planning to make. It might lead to higher quality posts which means my posts won't get as many oohs and ahs so my ego won't get stroked as much. Dang you "That Guy"! 🤣
 
I admit, I took a look over there. I'm exhausted, and all I did was read it. Honestly, it just reminds me, yet again, why except for an infrequent IG post, I have pretty much abandoned social media altogether. People are often just too peopley for me. Much preferred the pre-social blogging era, and the old style discussion forums (which is why I am here) and am honestly happy I found this group. Much more a fan of rational discussion, than baseless emotive arguments. If it's any consolation, I actually have found 'That Guy' to be very helpful here ☺️
 

Top 10 Trending Threads

Back
Top