Welcome to ScapeCrunch

We are ScapeCrunch, the place where planted aquarium hobbyists come to build relationships and support each other. When you're tired of doom scrolling, you've found your home here.

Waterbox Blue Friday

Its a fun hobby, but you have to find a way to minimize the maintenance or enjoy it. I have taken the approach of keeping everything simple. So my opinions might vary drastically from another person.

I have found freshwater to be easier with less maintenance. My biggest freshwater tank is only the 20g, so that is a factor. I also went in as a beginner selecting easy plants. However they are plants that I really like. I don't have any algae in the tank other than a few spots on old leaves. I trim those off. I also will trim down one of my plant groups each week. I use tap water (I have a well system) for water changes and do 25% weekly WC. I replace my filter floss, filter sock and wipe the inside glass. All of this takes me about 45 minutes and nothing is really that unenjoyable.

This is how saltwater compare and contrasts. Nutrient export is WAY more important in a saltwater. Like freshwater algae will take advantage of what is left over. The issue is that coral need very little nutrients from the water and grow much slower. The fastest growing coral would be a slower grower than a plant like annubias. With saltwater fish are way bigger and eat, poop way more. They battle the currents and on average swim around much more. So they eat more and poop more. They are also better looking so the desire to have more is greater (IMO). I think you idea of a large water change would be very helpful. However the cost of salt(water) is expensive and that adds up. It is also more of a pain to mix the salt than using RODI water and adding minerals for fresh. This is what I have grown tired of. Between the 4 reef tanks I have I prepare and use 15 gallons a week. Because I have a septic system, I feel I can not pour the old water down the drain. So I have to drag it outside and pour it in the gravel driveway. If I was on a municipal system, I would definitely pump it down the sink.

Back to nutrient export, I have decided running a bare bottom tank is the best way to keep an easily to maintain reef tank. Higher water flow and turnover keeps much of the detritus in the water column to be removed via mechanical filtration. It is harder to start the ecosystem without sand, but in my opinion for a long term sustained reef tank without overwhelming maintenance, it is the best way. Sand is an aesthetic choice. Most coral does not grow in sand or even near sand. We just have this image in out head of coral and sand. My advice for a newer to reef keeping person would be to start the tank with sand and then remove it down the road if/when the algae becomes a nuisance.

My 65 gallon reef tank has basically zero nuisance algae. There is always algae in a reef tank. It is a part of the ecosystem. The only spots in my reef tank that has nuisance algae are on 2 of my trochus snails who refuse to let my hermits graze on them. They jerk and buck them off like a bull! My bottom glass is covered by coralline algae now so it doesn't look un natural without the sand. I spend weekly 60-90 minutes on this tank. I scrape the film algae off the back wall and periodically scrape coralline algae off the front and side glass corners. I hate doing these things but they make the tank look much better. Then I clean the front and side glass. This next step is a key to success. I have a turkey baster like syringe with a right angle. I blow off all the detritus on the rock and blow out the detritus that settles in and under the rocks. You would be amazed how much builds up in one week. (After seeing this, I will never go back to sand.) lastly I vacuum out all of that detritus as I do the water change. I do a weekly 6-8 gallon WC on the 65g. Replace filter floss and filter sock, empty out the protein skimmer.

Regarding smaller reef tanks (the saltwater hobbyist consider under 30 gallons a nano tank....): I have had lots of success with smaller reef tanks. I usually end up selling them as they get boring. I currently have a 8 gallon at work that is on auto pilot. I honestly spend less than 30 minutes a week with maintenance. I do a weekly 1 gallon WC on it and a similar routine as above. With smaller tanks you are really limited to hermits and snails for algae removal. Most of you worker algae eating fish need 30 gallons or more. A larger water change would absolutely help maintain a cleaner aquarium. You just have to be OK with the add cost and trouble of salt/water.

I know this was more info than you were looking for, but hope some had some value.
 
Last edited:
Its a fun hobby, but you have to find a way to minimize the maintenance or enjoy it. I have taken the approach of keeping everything simple. So my opinions might vary drastically from another person.

I have found freshwater to be easier with less maintenance. My biggest freshwater tank is only the 20g, so that is a factor. I also went in as a beginner selecting easy plants. However they are plants that I really like. I don't have any algae in the tank other than a few spots on old leaves. I trim those off. I also will trim down one of my plant groups each week. I use tap water (I have a well system) for water changes and do 25% weekly WC. I replace my filter floss, filter sock and wipe the inside glass. All of this takes me about 45 minutes and nothing is really that unenjoyable.

This is how saltwater compare and contrasts. Nutrient export is WAY more important in a saltwater. Like freshwater algae will take advantage of what is left over. The issue is that coral need very little nutrients from the water and grow much slower. The fast growing coral would be a slower grower than a plant like annubias. With saltwater fish are way bigger and eat, poop way more. They battle the currents and on average swim around much more. So they eat more and poop more. They are also better looking so the desire to have more is greater (IMO). I think you idea of a large water change would be very helpful. However the cost of salt(water) is expensive and that adds up. It is also more of a pain to mix the salt than using RODI water and adding minerals for fresh. This is what I have grown tired of. Between the 4 reef tanks I have I prepare and use 15 gallons a week. Because I have a septic system, I feel I can not pour the old water down the drain. So I have to drag it outside and pour it in the gravel driveway. If I was on a municipal system, I would definitely pump it down the sink.

Back to nutrient export, I have decided running a bare bottom tank is the best way to keep an easily to maintain reef tank. Higher water flow and turnover keeps much of the detritus in the water column to be removed via mechanical filtration. It is harder to start the ecosystem without sand, but in my opinion for a long term sustained reef tank without overwhelming maintenance, it is the best way. Sand is an aesthetic choice. Most coral does not grow in sand or even near sand. We just have this image in out head of coral and sand. My advice for a newer to reef keeping person would be to start the tank with sand and then remove it down the road if/when the algae becomes a nuisance.

My 65 gallon reef tank has basically zero nuisance algae. There is always algae in a reef tank. It is a part of the ecosystem. The only spots in my reef tank that has nuisance algae are on 2 of my trochus snails who refuse to let my hermits graze on them. The jerk and buck them off like a bull! My bottom glass is covered by coralline algae now so it doesn't look un natural without the sand. I spend weekly 60-90 minutes on this tank. I scrape the film algae off the back wall and periodically scrape coralline algae off the front and side glass corners. I hate doing these things but they make the tank look much better. Then I clean the front and side glass. This next step is a key to success. I have a turkey baster like syringe with a right angle. I blow off all the detritus on the rock and blow out the detritus that settles in and under the rocks. You would be amazed how much builds up in one week. (After seeing this, I will never go back to sand.) lastly I vacuum out all of that detritus as I do the water change. I do a weekly 6-8 gallon WC on the 65g. Replace filter floss and filter sock, empty out the protein skimmer.

Regarding smaller reef tanks (the saltwater hobbyist consider under 30 gallons a nano tank....): I have had lots of success with smaller reef tanks. I usually end up selling them as they get boring. I currently have a 8 gallon at work that is on auto pilot. I honestly spend less than 30 minutes a week with maintenance. I do a weekly 1 gallon WC on it and a similar routine as above. With smaller tanks you are really limited to hermits and snails. Most of you worker algae eating fish need 30 gallons or more. A larger water change would absolutely help maintain a cleaner aquarium. You just have to be OK with the add cost and trouble of salt/water.

I know this was more info than you were looking for, but hope some had some value.
No this was a great perspective and I really appreciate this right up..
 

Top 10 Trending Threads

Back
Top