Welcome to ScapeCrunch

We are ScapeCrunch, the place where planted aquarium hobbyists come to build relationships and support each other. When you're tired of doom scrolling, you've found your home here.

Testing CO2 After Bottle Change

Joined
Nov 1, 2022
Messages
1,089
Reaction score
1,692
Location
Raleigh, NC US
I'd think it would be consistent since the pressure it controlled by a regulator and needle valve, but I'm finding I need to check my CO2 and sometimes readjust the flow after each bottle change. I definitely have to clean my diffuser regularly to keep the CO2 up, but I'm surprised changing bottles makes such a difference.

Is it like this for everyone else?
 
What is your go-to process for cleaning the diffuser plate? 🤔
I soak it in peroxide a bit, toothbrush, then re-soak a few more minutes, toothbrush, done.
If I've been slack in getting this done, the difference in fizz can be dramatic. That's sometimes all it takes to get my levels back up.
This time it was pretty clean.

Last time I tested my CO2, it was ~50+ppm (notwithstanding the inaccuracy from low KH, however E quing has been happy)
Changed the bottle Friday, it was 25ppm just now.
I say ~50 because once the test gets to 50, I don't test any further. 50ppm is what I need and more testing just wastes reagent $$$. As long as the shrimp aren't at the top of the water, I'm good. I always test at the same time when the lights come on.
My H Chai has started to melt some. So I felt something was off, however, I've been tinkering with the fert dozing a bit as well.
 
Last edited:
The only times I’ve noticed a change (outside of accidentally changing the dial) have been when I’ve changed between different sizes of tanks, going from 5 lb to 10 lb, or vice versa.
 
Ben, I notice this also. For what it's worth I use a 20lb bottle and a very cheap regulator. I just plan to readjust the regulator setting every time I swap a bottle.
I think I'm going to have to at least plan on testing on each swap. I'm just surprised it's so far off this time.
 
I'd think it would be consistent since the pressure it controlled by a regulator and needle valve, but I'm finding I need to check my CO2 and sometimes readjust the flow after each bottle change. I definitely have to clean my diffuser regularly to keep the CO2 up, but I'm surprised changing bottles makes such a difference.

Is it like this for everyone else?
This is the #1 reason I switched to using flowmeters instead of bubble counters or anything else.

For example, if my CO2 per minute is 30SCCM before the bottle change, I usually just need to dial it back to 30SCCM again, easy. I can do that with the needle valve, or adjusting the working pressure knob too, and finding a balance between the two. But, if it was 30SCCM before the change, and 30SCCM after the change, I know I'm good. Flowmeter for the win!
 
Last edited:
This is the #1 reason I switched to using flowmeters instead of bubble counters or anything else.
I looked at getting one for Christmas, but they seem so expensive. Maybe I'll splurge some other time. It might be particularly good on this tank since I'm always trying to grow the high CO2 stuff in it. When I get a second tank, it won't be so CO2 demanding.
 
I’m absent a flow meter as well, no bubble counter either. I guesstimated following my drop checker for a couple weeks and by listening for the purging in my Yugang reactor . I do find that I’m using more gas than I was but I’m fine with it as long as the co2 is plentiful.
 

Top 10 Trending Threads

Back
Top